Import Ref: 
68
Import Imported: 
1

 

 

This special edition of Talking Disputes series discussed the recent arbitral award in the investor-state dispute Philip Morris v. Uruguay (ICSID Case No. ARB/10/7). 

This case was filed by Swiss and Uruguayan subsidiaries of the tobacco giant Philip Morris International (jointly referred to as “Philip Morris” or the “Claimants”) in 2010, on the basis of the 1988 bilateral investment treaty (BIT) between Switzerland and Uruguay and the Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States (ICSID Convention).

In this dispute, Philip Morris took issue with Uruguay’s tobacco control measures including a single presentation requirement that allows only one variant of cigarettes per brand family and also the requirement of increasing the size of graphic health warnings from 50% to 80% appearing on cigarette packages.

In its July 2016 award, the tribunal held that a trademark holder does not enjoy an absolute right of use, free of regulation, and that the use of trademark in commerce is subject to the state’s regulatory power. The tribunal ultimately found that the measures were a valid exercise by Uruguay of its police powers for the protection of public health, and cannot constitute an expropriation of Philip Morris’ investment. The arbitrators also found no violation of the “fair and equitable treatment” requirement under the BIT. The tribunal considered among other issues that the World Health Organization’s Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) is a point of reference on the basis of which one could determine the reasonableness of the measures. The tribunal also dismissed Philip Morris’ other claims and ordered the Claimants to pay Uruguay $7 million as reimbursement of legal expenses.

Practical info

Venue: Room C1 (Petal 5), the Graduate Institute, Chemin Eugène-Rigot 2, 1202 Geneva

Registration: Registration is mandatory.  (Registration is now closed.)

Webcast: This event was streamed live online on the event page. 

[The views and opinions expressed in the event are those of the experts and do not necessarily reflect those of ICTSD and WTIA.]

We welcome your feedback on this event: https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/GXC35NJ

Undefined
Place: 
Geneva, Switzerland
Event type: 
Our events
Theme: 
TRADE LAW
Image: 
Promote to homepage: 
No
Updates: 
Investor-State Tribunal Dismisses Philip Morris Case Against Uruguay Cigarette Packaging El capítulo de inversión del TPP: retos y mejoras para MéxicoEditorial | Regímenes de inversión internacional: desafíos para el desarrollo sostenible“Llevar adelante la negociación con Europa, eso es absolutamente prioritario para Uruguay”Solución de diferencias en la OMC, desarrollo sostenible y América Latina: un repaso de las nuevas tendencias
Region: 
Global
Main Tag: 
Event
Language: 
English
Partners: 

Date period: 
Thursday, 27 October 2016 - 5:30pm